benjamin-farren - New York State Wildlife Conservation - The Inside Spread

Category: Policy

New York State Wildlife Conservation

Hunting has been a part of human culture for centuries, serving as a means of survival, a rite of passage, and a way to connect with nature. Today, hunting plays a crucial role in New York State wildlife conservation, contributing to the balance of ecosystems and supporting the survival of various species. However, the practice of hunting has been under scrutiny, particularly in the context of wildlife killing contests.

The Controversy Around Wildlife Killing Contests

Wildlife killing contests have been a longstanding tradition in many rural communities, including those in New York State. These contests, with names such as Predator Slam, Squirrel Scramble, and Final Fling for Fox, challenge hunters to bag the heaviest coyote or the largest number of squirrels to win a cash prize. While these events are often held in the name of fundraising and community building, they have recently come under scrutiny from animal rights activists who view them as senseless slaughters.

The controversy surrounding these contests has reached the legislative level, with a proposal to ban such contests recently approved by the New York State Legislature. The proposed law, which is currently under consideration by Governor Kathy Hochul, would make it illegal to organize, conduct, promote, or participate in competitions involving wildlife being taken for prizes or entertainment. However, the law would not apply to contests involving white-tailed deer, bear, and turkey, as existing hunting regulations, which include bag limits, tend to protect these creatures.

Opponents of the proposed ban argue that these contests are an integral part of rural life and culture. David Leibig, a rural upstate resident and executive director of the New York State Trappers Association, argues that the events draw families together and raise money for community groups such as fire departments. He also disputes the claim that these contests are “just a blood fest,” emphasizing that they have been held for decades around the nation.

One such event that has drawn both criticism and hundreds of participants is a three-day coyote hunt held in largely rural Sullivan County, northwest of New York City. The competition, which offers a top prize of $2,000 for the hunter who brings in the heaviest coyote, raises as much as $12,000 to help fund youth programs and the local fire department. John Van Etten, president of the Federation of Sportsmen’s Clubs of Sullivan County, argues that those who oppose the competition don’t fully understand it or the reasons why people hunt coyotes.

Despite the controversy, it’s important to note that these contests take place within existing hunting regulations and are defended as a way to keep wildlife populations in check, especially for coyotes, which are viewed as livestock-killing nuisances in some areas. However, ban supporters argue that the best available evidence does not support casting the competitions as coyote control. Instead, they claim that contests can actually spur coyote reproduction by destabilizing packs.

The Role of Hunting in New York State Wildlife Conservation

Contrary to the negative portrayal by some, hunting plays a significant role in New York State wildlife conservation. Regulated hunting is one of the most effective tools that state wildlife agencies can use to address overpopulation of certain species. Hunters directly support wildlife conservation in many ways, contributing to the success of various conservation efforts. For instance, the United States boasts the most successful wildlife management system in the world, largely due to the financial and physical contributions of hunters and anglers.

That point cannot be stressed enough: The reason that coyote and other wildlife populations need to be control is a direct effect from hunter and anglers spending their dollars on conservation causes like tags, hunting gear and donations to wildlife conservation organizations. While animal rights activist spend much of their dollars petitioning legislatures to make changes.


Conservation Successes due to Hunting

The impact of hunting on conservation is not limited to just one or two examples. Across the United States, hunting has played a pivotal role in the recovery of various species. Take the case of the American alligator, for instance. Once on the brink of extinction due to unregulated hunting and loss of habitat, the American alligator is now thriving thanks to strict hunting regulations and concerted conservation efforts. This success story underscores the positive impact of well-regulated hunting practices on wildlife conservation, demonstrating that hunting, when managed responsibly, can contribute significantly to the preservation of our natural ecosystems.

Hunting has played a significant role in New York State wildlife conservation, contributing to the balance of ecosystems and supporting the survival of various species. For instance, deer hunting in New York State is not only a popular recreational activity but also a crucial tool for managing deer populations. By keeping the deer population in check, hunting helps reduce negative impacts of deer overpopulation such as crop damage, vehicle collisions, and the spread of Lyme disease. This is just one example of how hunting contributes to New York State wildlife conservation, demonstrating that when done responsibly and ethically, hunting can play a vital role in preserving our natural ecosystems.

Addressing the Arguments of Animal Rights Activists

While animal rights activists argue against wildlife killing contests, it’s important to note that these contests take place within existing hunting regulations and have no significant impact on wildlife populations. Moreover, these contests often contribute to local economies, supporting community groups and funding youth programs.

The debate around wildlife killing contests highlights the need for a balanced approach to New York State wildlife conservation. While it’s crucial to ensure the ethical treatment of animals, it’s equally important to recognize the role of hunting in wildlife conservation. As hunters, we must continue to advocate for responsible hunting practices that support wildlife conservation, and educate others about the positive impact of these practices.

As we navigate this complex issue, let’s continue to promote responsible hunting and contribute to wildlife conservation efforts. Let’s engage in open dialogues, educate ourselves and others, and work towards solutions that respect both wildlife and our hunting heritage. Finally, speak with your state representatives especially if involves bans like this that can hurt New York State wildlife conservation efforts. Then get involved locally with wildlife conservation, if we are doing the work we will have the confidence and boldness to continue to do what is right.


**If you have a topic or story that you would like The Inside Spread to write about, reach out at or contact us here.**